I think it probably is less frustrating to non-theists. It is what keeps me from fully loving his books though. I agree that he is probably get kids to ask the questions but I don't feel he is encouraging them to find answers. Just to ask them. I give him credit for at least helping them get half of the way there.

And his lack of progress IS frustrating. Maybe it is all a facade to continue to reach new young people BUT if I take him for his word and it isn't a facade I can only shake my head in wonder sometimes. We are around the same age and I feel he exhibits a kind of arrested development. It is fine for HS students to identify with and find Holden Caufield admirable. There comes a time when you should outgrow him and move on.